|
Studio MIYABI specializes in the care and
conservation of Asian scroll paintings. As you are
most likely aware, scroll paintings require a
particular type of expertise and specialized
skills. Traning for this type of conservation is
normally not available in the United States. Many
museums with large Asian collections staff their
conservation departments with Chinese or Japanese
trained conservators.
With few conservators trained to handle scroll
paintings, museums and private collectors with
special projects or small Asian collections often
have difficulty locating a conservator to help them
on a limited or short-term basis. Having recognized
and hoping to meet this need within the Asian art
community, I have established a conservation studio
that will offer conservation expertise on a
contractual basis.
ASIAN ART CONSERVATION IN AMERICA
By: Ryo Nishiumi
Over the years there have been numerous Japanese
screens collected by individuals and museums in the
West, especially in the United States and Europe.
As the screens age and need restoration, it is
becoming more and more obvious that there is a
shortage of conservators in the West who are
trained in the traditional Japanese techniques of
complete screen restoration. In fact, today there
may be less than ten such conservators outside of
Japan. In addition, materials traditionally used
for screen restoration are often not available
outside the Orient. Of course it is hoped that in
the future there will be more Westerners who are
trained in traditional Japanese restoration and
that materials which are now difficult to obtain
will be more accessible. It can also be expected
that indigenous American and European materials and
methods will be substituted, by those of us working
in the West, for traditional Japanese methods and
materials whenever the western methods and
materials prove to be more suitable. At my studio,
for example, we are exploring the use of Honeybomb
( a man-made hexongally-celled paper core ) as a
substitute for the traditional wooden undercore of
screens.
During the past 25 years of conservation
treatment in America, I have encountered many
problems. Some of the problems are easily solved
such as improper handling techniques and incorrect
temperature and humidity settings. The more serious
problems for me are related to restoration
techniques and materials. For example, it is now
easy but expensive to purchase quality
washi ( paper ); however in America and
Europe, to purchase the wood for the screens
undercore that supports the six paper layers (
which in turn support the artwork ) is still very
difficult. In Japan white cedar called
shiromi, Japanese cypress and
kiri ( paulownia ) are used for the
undercores with cedar being the most popular.
Outside Japan it is very difficult to obtain the
shiromi type of cedar. Therefore, in
the past, pine has substituted for Japanese
shiromi cedar both at the Freer Gallery
and at my studio. As shown in the photograph there
have been examples in which acid from the
replacement pine undercore has damaged the
painting. If at all possible a screens old
undercore is reused because old cores give off
virtually no acid. Unfortunately sometimes because
of severe damage to the undercore, it must be
replaced. This is a problem for us because American
woods are more acidic than Japanese cedar, cypress
or palownia and are often milled differently. In
addition, in many parts of America and Europe
finding a carpenter who can build a traditional
Japanese style undercore is not always possible.
For these reasons I have begun experimenting with
adapting western conservation materials in the
restoration of traditional Japanese screens. More
specifically I have been looking for an alternative
to the screens wooden undercore. Currently,
we are using traditional methods but substituting
American poplar for Japanese woods. The alternative
we are looking at now is a man-made material called
Honeycomb. Honeycomb has all the physical
properties necessary for a substitute for the
traditional undercore: it has the ability to expand
and contract with the changing temperature and
humidity; it is durable and resists warping and it
has an acceptable pH level. The advantages of
honeycomb are that it is easily accessible, can be
purchased locally and it is usable as is. Only the
addition of the paper for the hinges is required
without the necessity of applying six layers of
paper as a Japanese undercore would require.
Finally, it meets the same requirements as a
traditional Japanese undercore: namely, it supports
the artwork on a flat plane while at the same time
it absorbs excess moisture when the humidity is
high and on dryer days it gradually releases
moisture. Thus there are no rapid changes in a
screens moisture content can often lead to
either horizontal or vertical tears. Two other
important characteristics that lead me to say that
Honeycomb appears to be an even better material
than the traditional Japanese undercore made with
an American wood, are that Honeycomb is acid free
and therefore presents no risk to the artwork of
causing acid burn and that it is less attractive to
insects.
Of course Honeycomb has not passed the final
test the test of time as have traditional
Japanese methods and materials. It is therefore
best to adhere to them as much as possible. However
when the necessity arises as it does upon occasion
for us in the west, we must be willing to be
inventive. Rather than be discouraged by the lack
of traditional materials used in Japan, I think we
can view the problems that arise from doing Asian
conservation in the West as exciting challenges to
be successfully overcome. We will continue as much
as possible to follow traditional ways while being
constantly on the lookout for innovative solutions
to the problems that arise. Just as many
traditional Asian conservation techniques and
materials have been successfully adapted for use in
Western conservation so too is it reasonable to
expect that some Western methods and materials will
be successfully adapted for Asian conservation.
|